Payment Depot vs. Fattmerchant: Which Solution is Right for Your Business?

By Jasmine Glasheen

Choosing between payment processing providers is a challenge — especially when you come across two payment processing companies that seem quite similar at first glances, such as Payment Depot and Fattmerchant. 

Since both Payment Depot and Fattmerchant offer membership-based credit card processing and they both offer 0 percentage markups on transactions, it can be difficult to know how to differentiate between the two, much less to choose the right merchant services provider for your business

However, there are a few clear-cut differences between Payment Depot vs Fattmerchant. We will evaluate both businesses by the following 5 factors: 

  1. Features and Capabilities
  2. Pricing
  3. Customer Service
  4. Reviews and Reputation 
  5. Hardware 

So, let’s take a look at each business’ offerings in each of these categories so that you can make the right informed a decision on which payment processor is right for you.

At a glance

Features and Capabilities

Payment Depot Features 

Payment Depot came before Fattmerchant and it offers more options to help mid-sized business owners save money with membership-based pricing. 

Payment Depot offers a free payment gateway, chargeback, and risk monitoring, rate protection, and next-day funding to all of its customers — so you have access to all of these features even if you’re only paying $49 a month + interchange for basic merchant services. 

What’s more, Payment Depot proactively includes a PCI certificate in each membership plan as a means of protecting its members. There’s also no cancellation fee if you decide to end your membership. 

The included features become even more enticing if you purchase a larger plan, including 27/7 in-house customer service, free terminal upgrades every 2 years, a free standard terminal, a free mobile reader, a free pinpad, and more.

Fattmerchant Features 

Fattmerchant’s features are very similar to Payment Depot’s. Fattmerchant has no cancellation fees, no statement fees, no batch fees, and 0% markups. 

Fattmerchant’s “Omni-platform” makes it easy to track transactional data. Fattmerchant also easily integrates with Quickbooks, offers next-day funding, and PCI compliance support to make sure your customer payment data protection is up-to-par. 

Costs

Payment Depot Pricing

Payment Depot charges a monthly membership fee, in addition to a set amount per transaction plus interchange. While Fattmerchant only offers 2 price tiers, Payment Depot offers 4, so if you’re a lower volume retailer you won’t wind up paying for features you won’t use. Here are Payment Depot’s membership prices: 

  • Basic Plan: Companies processing under $25,000 a month will pay $49/month plus a 15-cent transaction fee and interchange
  • Most Popular Plan: Companies processing up to $75,000 a month will pay $79/month plus a 10-cent transaction fee and interchange. 
  • Best Value Plan: Companies processing up to $200,000 a month will pay $99/month plus 7-cents per transaction and interchange. 
  • Premier Plan: Any company processing over $200,000 a month will pay $199/month plus 5-cents per transaction and interchange. 

It’s also important to note that Payment Depot is willing to negotiate on the per-transaction fee. For instance, the company has several clients on $49 a month, but are paying $0.05 per transaction instead of $0.15. Contact the Payment Depot team and see if there’s a way to lower your rates. 

Fattmerchant Pricing

Fattmerchant’s fees are a big draw for uninitiated retailers. Who doesn’t love the sound of 0% markup and flat-rate credit card processing? Yet Fattmerchant’s 0% markup refers only to percentage-based markups, not to all markups altogether. You will still be charged per transaction, it’s just a set amount instead of a percentage of your profits — yet the fact that they don’t take a percentage still makes Fattmerchant’s rates more cost-effective than most payment processors. Fattmerchant offers 2 membership options:

  • Companies processing less than $500,000 a year will pay $99 a month + 8 cents per transaction plus interchange. 
  • Those processing more than $500,000 a year will pay $199/month plus 6 cents per transaction plus interchange

If your company processes big-ticket transactions or large sales, using a membership-based payment processor such as Fattmerchant can help you save a significant amount of payment processing. However, Fattmerchant is not the most cost-effective membership-based payment processor. As mentioned earlier, Payment Depot’s rates are lower than Fattmerchant’s, in addition to offering more membership options for small to mid-sized business owners. 

Customer Support

Payment Depot Customer Service 

Payment Depot offers award-winning 24/7 in-house customer service. They don’t outsource their customer service queries to a third-party provider, so you can touch base with a Payment Depot employee who knows their stuff every single time you call in. 

Fattmerchant Customer Service

Fattmerchant’s website has a high-functioning search bar that lets customers find their own answers. Fattmerchant offers 24/7 call-in technical support and customers can also fill out a customer service request ticket on Fattmerchant’s website to have their account manager respond to their questions. 

Reviews and Reputation

Payment Depot Reviews 

Payment Depot is a Better Business Accredited Business and it’s BBB rating is an A+ (and if you’re familiar with the Better Business Bureau, you know how rare it is to see a credit card processing company with this rating). While many companies claim to be no-hassle and transparent about their fees, a quick background check on these businesses reveals that they aren’t as transparent as they would have new customers believe. Payment Depot, on the other hand, is the real deal. 

It’s important to note, however, that Payment Depot does not accept high-risk merchants, meaning businesses of questionable legality, those with a high fraud rate, questionable practices, or those who process a lot of high-ticket transactions via credit card may not be accepted. Contact Payment Depot’s 24/7 in-house customer service team to find out if your business falls into this category.

Payment Depot also has several positive reviews from merchants and industry websites. Check them out here.

Fattmerchant Reviews 

Fattmerchant has a lot of happy customers, which can be attributed to the fact that customers can save $513 a month by switching to Fattmerchant’s membership-based business model. Fattmerchant’s BBB rating is an A-, which is obviously nothing to sneeze at. However, it is concerning that unhappy customers cited unexpected fees as their main complaint. 

Equipment

Payment Depot Hardware

Payment Depot has a wide variety of free credit card processing solutions for retailers including countertop and wireless physical terminals, wireless mobile card readers, and ultra-modern Clover POS stations, virtual terminals, and Payment Depot can easily integrate with most online shopping cart and content management systems. 

Fattmerchant Hardware

Fattmerchant has a few different terminals options: Dejavoo terminals (which include both standalone and integrated payment options), Pinpad devices by Veriphone, and BBPOS mobile payment platforms. Each option has an EMV chip reader and a card swipe reader, as well the option to accept both Apple Pay and Android Pay.

Choosing a Payment Processor

The bottom line? Fattmerchant and Payment Depot run very similar business models, but the latter has a slight edge. 

Payment Depot has been around longer and has more membership options for mid to small-sized business owners. And Payment Depot’s reviews reflect their position as category leader… in addition to a phenomenal BBB rating of A+, Payment Depot saves merchants an average of $400 a month. Get in touch with one of Payment Depot’s award-winning customer service reps to learn how the platform can help your business save on credit card processing.